How Ranked Choice Voting Changes the Voting Experience on Election Day

Ranked Choice Voting (RCV) is a voting method that permits citizens to rank candidates on the ballot in order of preference.

The voter’s preferred candidate is marked as her first choice, and then the voter can mark the remaining candidates as being her second choice, third choice, etc., all the way down the entire list of candidates. A voter can also just list her first choice, or she can rank as many choices as there are candidates on a ranked choice ballot – it’s up to the individual voter.

When ballots are counted, if no “first-choice” candidate wins a majority (over 50%) of the vote, election officials assess the remaining candidates’ votes in an “instant runoff” to identify the winning candidate. The tabulation process goes like this:

• In the first round, the candidate with the most votes – let’s call her Candidate A – got 35% of the total vote. As Candidate A didn’t get a majority, the vote moves to a second tally. In that second round, the candidate with the fewest total votes is dropped – let’s call him Candidate B. If a voter’s ballot has Candidate B marked as their number one choice, that choice is eliminated and now the voter’s number two choice moves into their number one slot. If the voter picked Candidate A as her number two choice, that vote is now added to Candidate A’s total. But if the voter picked Candidate C, the vote goes into Candidate C’s column.

• The ballots are then counted, and if Candidate A now has won a true majority of voters - with over 50% - then the election is over and Candidate A is the winner. But if she still doesn’t have a majority, the same process is repeated: the candidate with the lowest total number of votes in the second tally is eliminated, and the ballots that ranked him as the first-choice candidate now move the remaining second-choice candidate up to number one. Again, if Candidate A was the number two choice, she becomes the number one choice and gets the vote in her column. But if Candidate C was the former number two choice, he becomes the new number one and gets that voter’s vote.

• If Candidate A now has a majority of the vote, she wins. But if she hasn’t secure over 50% of the first-choice votes, then the process repeats with an “instant runoff”: eliminate the last place candidate; and for those ballots that listed this candidate as number one, move the number two choice up to the number one slot; then count the votes and see what the tally shows. It’s possible that Candidate A will eventually win, but it’s also possible that Candidate C was so strong as a second, third, or even fourth choice, that the process of eliminating the loser of each round will give Candidate C an eventual majority.

And that’s the most important aspect of RCV: over 50% of voters will have chosen the eventual winner, even if she wasn’t necessarily their first choice ...

An RCV election is truly anyone’s race, and that’s why ranked choice voting elections provide such a powerful force for democracy: when all votes matter, then all candidates must do a better job or campaigning to everyone.

Indeed, several candidates may engage in coalition building with one another in an attempt to sway voters to pick both or all three of them ...

All eligible voters are now seen as part of a potential constituency, and every candidate must tailor policies and messages toward a greater, more inclusive group of citizens. Less alienation, more bridge-building. Adoption of ranked choice voting and instant runoff voting methods may help reduce the increasing polarization we currently see between our country’s political parties.

In recent months, RCV is gaining more attention ...

as scores of municipalities and a growing number of states are switching to this method of voting. In fact, over a dozen states, 52 cities, including Minneapolis, and 1 county, will likely use RCV in their next election, according to FairVote.org, an 30-year old non-profit based in Cincinnati, OH that advocates on behalf of this voting system. In the upcoming midterm election, you may find a ballot measure asking you whether you’d like your jurisdiction to adopt the reform!
 

Statewide Use of Ranked Choice Voting

2022 State and Federal Elections (including state primary elections and presidential elections)

• • Military and Overseas Voters
  • Republican Primaries
  • Democratic Primaries
  • Alaska
  • Maine
  • Alabama
  • Arkansas
  • Georgia
  • Louisiana
  • Mississippi
  • South Carolina
  • Indiana
  • Virginia
  • Alaska
  • Hawaii
  • Kansas
  • Nevada
  • Wyoming

Source: Compiled from FairVote.org “Where Ranked Choice Voting is Used” April 2022

New York City also used ranked choice voting ...

for local elections for mayor, city council, and other offices in 2021; it will use it for all special elections going forward. Utah has also used ranked choice voting in municipal elections. The trend, as you can see, isn’t limited to red or blue states, middle of the country or bi-coastal areas. It’s catching on precisely because the practice better engages voters and encourages their participation; no longer will they say, oh, I can’t select Candidate Y on the ballot because he’ll never win. Instead, voters can select their top choices - even if pie in the sky - while additionally ranking all candidates, just to be pragmatic. And candidates know this. As a result, it’s on them to reach out to as many voters as possible to get on the map.  

If you’re interested in seeing more data about actual elections ...

and who wins RCV elections, FairVote.org shares extensive research on these topics. Interestingly, the first round winner usually does win the election, but not always.

RCV can make our elections much more representative ...

of the true will of the majority, but if you feel stressed about changing the way you vote to ranked choice voting, you can still just vote for a single favorite candidate as you’ve always done. Your candidate will continue to be part of a run-off as long as your candidate doesn’t move into last place and is eliminated completely. Ranked-choice voting can be used in both single-winner elections or multi-winner ones, where more than one candidate is elected to the same office

We often hear that democracy is about majority rule, but many elections are actually decided by pluralities rather than majorities. RCV is designed to make our democracy more representative by having automatic run-off elections take place following an election until one candidate reaches the majority threshold. Please visit Fairvote.org for more information.